The ER Doc as Primary Care Physician

emergency_room_591 One of the numerous inefficiencies of the American health care finance system is that hospitals have been forced to pay high compensation to attract doctors into emergency room care.

The primary reason for this has been that many uninsured and underinsured consumers use the ER for non-emergency medical matters that would be better and more efficiently handled by an internist or family practitioner in their private office. This disturbing trend has been growing for many years and likely will be made even worse by Obamacare.

Turns out that the ER doc-as-primary-care-physician is also having some unintended consequences with regard to patients, as related by an internist/hospitalist friend of mine:

So, I get a call from the ER today – new doc fresh out of the ER training program tells me she has a patient there she wants me to admit for a cardiac workup.

Says that the patient has a history of “heart problems” and that the patient said that she was having chest pain “just like before my bypass.”

So, I go down to the ER – I look at the patient’s chart and note that her primary complaint when she arrived there was fever and vomiting.  I note that her cardiac evaluation so far was normal.  I looked at her EKG – normal.  I pulled up her chest x-ray – normal. And no sign of any telltale median sternotomy wires that are standard post-CABG.  Hmm…

So, I go in to talk to the patient.  She tells me that she has “chest pain,” and epigastric pain, and fever, and chills, and nausea, and vomiting. I examine her and note that there is no CABG scar on her chest.  Hmm….

So, I ask her, “Tell me about your bypass.”

“You mean my gastric bypass?”

Turns out she never has had any heart problems.

Turns out she had a cardiac cath 15 months ago before her gastric surgery – stone cold normal.

Turns out the ER doc stopped listening as soon as she heard “chest pain” and “bypass.”

So, I put her in the hospital to treat her viral gastroenteritis with IV fluids and nausea meds.  And I will sent her home in the morning, feeling all better.

And I take solace in the fact that ER docs are paid at least 50% more than I am.

Well, not really, about the solace thing, that is .  .  .

To make matters worse, in previous times, the ER doctor’s superiors would have castigated her for her stupidity and intellectual laziness.  However, if that were to occur today, each of the doctors criticizing the ER doc would probably be labeled as a “disruptive physician” and referred to a series of sensitivity counseling sessions.

This is not going to turn out well.

One thought on “The ER Doc as Primary Care Physician

  1. as a private internist i agree with this doctor’s characterization. in my hospital the emergency room doctors are almost always as bad as described and the ability to get them to improve is limited, as described.
    i do not happen to agree that they are highly paid—only that they are overpaid for such low quality work.

Leave a Reply