Richard Z. Chesnoff, author of “Pack of Thieves” about the Nazi plundering of European Jews during the WWII era, has long been one of America’s most prominent reporters on foreign affairs. Richard is also the brother of my old friend David Z. Chesnoff, who is one of Las Vegas’ most prominent criminal defense lawyers (and also Britney Spears‘ lawyer in her recent annulment case, but that’s another story).
In this NY Daily News op-ed today, Richard insightfully and succinctly explains Ariel Sharon‘s innovative withdrawal plan in regard to moving the chronically intractable Israeli-Palestinian conflict toward resolution:
Sharon’s plan is brilliant in its simplicity – a sort of uncontestable, one-way divorce. Unwilling to wait any longer for the Palestinians to stop terror and negotiate peace seriously, Sharon plans single-handedly to disengage Israeli forces from Gaza, withdraw the 7,000 Jewish settlers who currently live there, turn control of the desert strip over to the Palestinians and begin to do the same in the West Bank by dismantling some Israeli settlements there as well.
At the same time, Sharon announced that Israel plans to complete the controversial security barricade it has been building to keep out Palestinian suicide bombers. Moreover, until a final peace settlement is drawn up, several significant West Bank settlements will remain on the Israeli side of the barricade.
Of course, Sharon doesn’t want the Palestinians to see Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza as a reward for Arab terrorism. He has been making sure to drive that point home by weakening the terrorists before the Israeli Army pulls out. Hence, the recent targeted killing of Hamas leader Sheik Ahmed Yassin and Saturday’s successful hit on Abdel Aziz Rantisi, the pediatrician-cum-killer who took over from Yassin. In case Hamas & co. still don’t get the message, the Israelis also have announced that even after withdrawal, their army will counterstrike if Gaza-based terrorism continues.
One of the best parts of Sharon’s plan is his offer to turn over the buildings and homes in Israel’s soon-to-be-abandoned Gaza settlements to needy Palestinian families. There’s one condition: Some international body will have to guarantee that the homes actually go to refugee families and not to Hamas terrorists or friends of Arafat and other well-connected Palestinians. Without that guarantee, Sharon said, he’ll have the settlements dynamited before the Israelis leave.
And then there is the most important of all declarations: America is backing the Israelis on their position that the so-called right of return is valid only for entry into a future Palestinian state and not to the Jewish state, thus thwarting the Arab attempt to destroy Israel by cramming millions of so-called Palestinian refugees down its throat.
And Richard concludes with an observation and a recommendation for the Palestinians:
The Palestinians have a long history of rejecting Israeli offers, only to see the dream of peace, prosperity and their own state recede farther over the horizon. This time, they should accept Sharon’s plan not as an outrageous insult but as a great opportunity.
Above all, they should remember that next time, the chances are that they’ll be offered even less.
Very well said. And I rarely agree with much that the punditocracy says on Israel. You might also run a Google search for anything written by Yossi Klein HaLevi. He’s outstanding.
Richard Chesnoff is one of America’s best writers on Israeli politics, which are not well understood generally over here. The thing that is most fascinating about Sharon’s plan is that he is literally using the vacuum in Palestinian leadership as a means for progress rather than an impediment to progress.