The media is all aflutter with the fact that the Stros have never beaten the Braves in three previous playoffs (in 1997, 1999, and 2001), but that fact is irrelevant to the current series. Only five of the Stros’ 25 man roster were even on the 2001 club (Bags, Bidg, Ausmus, Viz, and Berkman) and the same roster turnover is true for the Braves. So, these are different teams at a different time, and what has occurred in the past is largely just the stuff of baseball myths that media types enjoy discussing while trying to figure out something perceptive to say.
In its essence, baseball is a simple game. While at bat, a club tries to score more runs than its opposition. While in the field, the club tries to get three outs each inning before the opposition scores as many runs as the club has scored. Thus, creating runs while hitting, and saving runs while pitching and playing defense, are the most important indicators of success in baseball. That’s why I like the statistics of runs created against average (“RCAA”) and runs saved against average (“RSAA” and RCAA are explained here) — they are solid reflections of how a player and a team stacks up against an average player and an average team in their league at any particular point in time.
Based on RCAA and RSAA, the Braves should beat the Stros in this series, but not by much. Moreover, based on RCAA and RSAA, the Cubs and the Giants should have beaten out the Stros for the Wild Card Playoff spot, so the statistics are simply indicators of probable performance, not dispositive predictive tools. The nature of human performance generally and the charm of baseball in particular is the unpredictability of it all.
Since my most recent periodic review of the Stros hitters’ RCAA and the pitchers’ RSAA, the Stros overtook both the Giants and the Cubs in the NL Wild Card playoff race, and the clubs’ final RCAA and RSAA bear out what happened. Here are the Stros hitters’ final RCAA numbers, courtesy of Lee Sinins, through the end of the regular season:
Lance Berkman 69
Carlos Beltran 46 (28 with the Stros, 18 with the Royals)
Jeff Bagwell 17
Jeff Kent 12
Mike Lamb 11
Craig Biggio 8
Jason Lane 3
Eric Bruntlett 2
Willy Taveras 0
Chris Tremie 0
Jason Alfaro -2
Chris Burke -3
Orlando Palmeiro -4
Richard Hidalgo -9
Adam Everett -11
Morgan Ensberg -12
Jose Vizcaino -14
Raul Chavez -19
Brad Ausmus -26
After falling back to ninth a week before the end of the regular season, the Stros’ seven game winning streak to close out the season was bolstered by another surge in hitting that resulted in the Stros finishing seventh out of the 16 National League teams in RCAA (50), while the Braves finished fifth (60 RCAA). Frankly, that means the teams are about equal in hitting, as the Stros RCAA would be 8 points higher than the Braves had Beltran played with the club the entire season.
Insmuch as the Stros were at 17 RCAA a week ago, their hitting over the last week of the season was flat remarkable. Berkman and Beltran concluded monster years, and Bags and Bidg rebounded nicely after their lull following the earlier 12 game winning streak. Moreover, after being essentially an average National League hitter for the entire season, Jeff Kent went nuclear in the last week of the season and improved his RCAA from 1 to 12. Jason Lane also improved notably over that time, raising his -2 RCAA to a plus 3 by the end of regular season.
Now, here are the Braves’ individual RCAA figures:
J.D. Drew 66
Eli Marrero 14
Marcus Giles 13
Chipper Jones 11
Johnny Estrada 9
Julio Franco 6
Charles Thomas 5
Adam LaRoche 2
Rafael Furcal 1
Damon Hollins 1
Andruw Jones 0
Dewayne Wise -5
Wilson Betemit -6
Nick Green -8
Jesse Garcia -9
Mike Hessman -9
Eddie Perez -11
Mark DeRosa -20
In effect, the Braves have an outstanding hitter in Drew, who is almost equal to Berkman, but then a big dropoff to their second best hitter — there is clearly no Beltran-caliber second best hitter on the Braves. That is an advantage for the Stros, but it is offset by the fact that the Stros are pulled down by the amount of play that deficient hitters Ausmus, Chavez, Viz, and Ensberg receive. Stros manager Phil Garner would be well-advised to play the much more productive Lamb during the playoffs over Ensberg.
The big difference in the Braves and the Stros is in pitching, where the Braves are stronger even though the Stros’ pitching staff is quite good. Here are the Stros pitchers’ RSAA:
Roger Clemens 32
Brad Lidge 26
Roy Oswalt 22
Wade Miller 10
Dan Miceli 6
Octavio Dotel 5
Andy Pettitte 4
Chad Qualls 3
Russ Springer 3
Dan Wheeler 3
Darren Oliver 1
Brandon Backe 0
Mike Gallo -2
Chad Harville -2
David Weathers -2
Jeremy Griffiths -3
Ricky Stone -3
Kirk Bullinger -6
Jared Fernandez -6
Pete Munro -9
Carlos Hernandez -10
Brandon Duckworth -11
Tim Redding -15
The Stros are fourth among the 16 National League teams with a team RSAA of 46, which is the position that the Stros’ staff has been for most of the second half of the season. On the other hand, the Braves staff’s RSAA is a stout 89, which is second only to the Cubs’ staff that measured a heady 121 on the season (how again did the Cubs blow their lead in the Wild Card Playoff race?).
Clemens, Lidge and Oswalt are three of the best pitchers in baseball, and that’s a good nucleus for a short series. Miceli has bounced back well from his three week stint on the DL with pink eye, but beyond those four pitchers, the Stros are relying on a slew of young and not so young pitchers who are average or barely above average. Inasmuch as all of those pitchers seem to be pitching well right now (particularly the irrepressible Backe), the Stros may be able to bob and weave through a five game series with this bunch. However, in the longer seven game series in the LCS and the World Series, that lack of quality depth might get exposed. Unless, of course, these fellas simply step up on this national stage and continue to improve as they have over the past couple of weeks. I’m through doubting this bunch of competitors.
Here are the Braves pitchers’ individual RSAA:
Jaret Wright 21
Antonio Alfonseca 14
John Smoltz 14
Horacio Ramirez 13
John Thomson 13
Juan Cruz 12
Kevin Gryboski 8
Paul Byrd 5
Russ Ortiz 4
Roman Colon 2
Chris Reitsma 2
Tom Martin 1
Dan Meyer 1
Tim Drew 0
Mike Hampton 0
Sam McConnell 0
C.J. Nitkowski 0
Armando Almanza -2
Will Cunnane -4
Jose Capellan -6
Travis Smith -9
Jaret Wright, the Braves first game pitcher against Clemens, has pitched basically as well as Oswalt this season, so he is darn good pitcher. But interestingly, the rest of the Braves staff is essentially a bunch of well above-average and just above average pitchers, but none which had the seasons of Clemens, Lidge or Oswalt. Thus, the depth of the Braves’ pitching gives them an advantage, but the starting pitching matchups for the first three games favor the Stros:
Game One: Clemens (32 RSAA) v. Wright (21 RSAA)
Game Two: Roy O (22 RSAA) v. Mike Hampton (0 RSAA)
Game Three: Brandon Backe (0 RSAA) v. John Thomson (13 RSAA)
So, despite the Braves greater depth in quality pitching, this is really a very even series based upon the production of the respective teams’ players at this time. That’s why small adjustments such as playing Lamb over Ensberg and perhaps giving the emerging Lane some swings for Bidg could be the difference between winning and losing this series. Here’s hoping that Manager Garner can continue to pull the right strings that he so effectively selected during the drive for the Wild Card playoff spot.
Now, here are some other observations on the final statistics from the regular season:

Although the Cubs pitching was the best in the National League by far, their hitting went into the tank. As the Stros climbed from an RCAA of 18 to 50 in the last week of the season, the Cubs’ RCAA fell from 17 to 2 during the same week. Say bye-bye, Sammy!

Although the Giants’ 90 RCAA was stout and second best in the league behind the Cards’ astronomical 152, they lost the Wild Card Playoff race because of their lack of balance. The Giants’ pitching staff’s RSAA was only 16. And even the Giants’ RCAA is somewhat deceptive because of how top-loaded it is — the incredible Barry Bonds had a league-leading RCAA of 152 alone!

And let’s take a look at the key players that the Stros traded away either before or during this season:

Billy Wagner: 10 RSAA or slightly better than Dan Miceli.

Octavio Dotel: 3 RSAA or about like Chad Qualls.

Richard Hidalgo: -20 RCAA or worse then Raul Chavez (19). Ugh!

John Buck: -9 RCAA or about like Adam Everett.

Inasmuch as the Stros essentially got Beltran in return for Dotel and Buck, even a numbskull could evaluate that as a good trade. However, GM Gerry Hunsicker and Stros’ owner Drayton McLane both came under severe media criticism for the Wagner and Hidalgo trades, which got rid of huge salaries on players of declining production. Those critical media types owe Messrs. McLane and Hunsicker an apology, but I doubt that they will even get an objective evaluation of the trades in the mainstream media, much less an apology. So it goes.