2006 Weekly local football review

kevin Kolb.jpgBills 24 Texans 21

Key note to first year Texans’ coach Gary Kubiak — the Texans (3-7) are not yet good enough to put the offense in a phone booth while trying to milk the clock with a narrow 4th quarter lead. It’s pretty hard for the Texans to lose a game in which their generally anemic offense generates almost 400 yards, but giving up over 200 yards passing and two long TD passes to the eminently forgettable Bills QB J.P. Losman in the 1st quarter is a good way to start to do it. And then making only four first downs in the second half (the Bills had as many in the game-winning drive) and just one in the fourth quarter is the way to finish it off. By the way, does anyone else think that John McClain’s entry into the world of blogging has actually improved his analysis of Texans football (blog post on yesterday’s game is here)? The Texans go on the road the next two weeks to meet the Jets (5-5) and the Raiders (2-8) before returning home the following week to meet the Titans (3-7).

Houston Cougars 23 Memphis 20 OT

In another example of what can go wrong when a team quits taking measured risks with its offense while sitting on a 4th quarter lead, the Coogs (9-3, 7-2) survived a blocked field goal returned for a Memphis (1-10, 0-7) TD in the last two minutes to win the game in overtime. Houston has an extremely difficult offense to defend when they are clicking on all cylinders, but their defense is simply not good enough for the offense to play conservatively after building a lead. The Cougars now get Thanksgiving week off before hosting the C-USA championship game on Friday evening, December 1 against probably Southern Miss (6-4, 5-2).

Rice 18 East Carolina 17

The Owls (6-5, 5-2) continue to make me look prescient for my early season prediction that they were going to surprise quite a few people this season so long as they could avoid decimating injuries during their brutal early season schedule. This win was particularly impressive in that the Owls pulled it off after losing stellar QB Chase Clement over the final quarter and a half. If the Owls can get Clement back next week and beat SMU (6-5, 4-3) at home, then they will likely be C-USA’s representative in the Ft. Worth Bowl, the Owls first bowl appearance in 45 years. First year Rice coach Todd Graham is the coach of the year in my book.

The Texas Longhorns and the Texas Aggies were off this week in preparation for their annual day-after-Thanksgiving showdown in Austin.

Bo Schembechler, R.I.P.

Schembechler.jpgFormer University of Michigan >Bo Schembechler — one of the true characters in the storied history of Big Ten football — died yesterday, adding another emotional element to today’s big game between No. 2 Michigan and No. 1 Ohio State. Here is the Detroit Free Press coverage on Schembechler’s life and death, including Schembechler biographer Mitch Albom’s heartfelt tribute.
I never had the opportunity to meet Coach Schembechler, but I have long felt connected to him. Many of my friends in the coaching profession knew and enjoyed him, particularly how he loved to compete. Even though my family was from Iowa, we always suffered with Schembechler during Michigan’s long drought in the Rose Bowl when it seemed as if the Pac-10 teams were always flying by Bo’s Michigan teams. Although Schembechler was 12 years younger than my father, the two of them were both active and highly-motivated men who had heart attacks and by-pass surgery at a time when that surgery was still a somewhat iffy proposition. They both then returned to their respective professions and worked productively for many years, representing two good examples of the value of that surgical procedure. Schembechler even died in the same manner as my father, suddenly of a heart attack while enjoying what he loved to do. These were two men who were not about to let a little health problem interfere with enjoying the fullness of life.

Continue reading

Maybe this will make the Longhorns feel better

ohio_stadium3.jpgAs noted in this earlier post, Las Vegas Sports Consultants publishes their OddsMakers Top 25 each week in which they rank major college football teams based on injuries, performance, skill and game location, not on won-loss record and not on which teams will draw the greatest or least betting action (they leave that for the bookies). The poll is becoming quite popular with the betting markets and is currently published every Monday in the Las Vegas Review-Journal.
Inasmuch as this ranking is based on the profit motive (LVSC is attempting to attract betting customers through the accuracy of its research), my sense is that the OddsMakers Top 25 ends up being a more accurate ranking than the traditional polls, which tend to be plagued by the subjective bias of its voters. For your weekend football viewing pleasure, The following is this week’s Oddsmakers Top 25 poll with the team record and BCS ranking in parentheses:

Continue reading

Fred Weary’s adventure

Weary_Fred.jpgH’mm, now let me get this one straight.
As Stephanie Stradley reports in detail (John McClain’s comments are here), Texans offensive guard Fred Weary left work at Reliant Park a little after noon on Tuesday. Weary, who is 6’4″, 308 lbs., was followed by a couple of Houston policemen in a squad car as he drove through the Reliant Park area to get on the South Loop and head home.
The officers followed Weary for about six miles and determined that he was “acting suspiciously” and “looking at (them) on several occasions.” After seeing him commit the heinous offense of making a bad lane change, the crack team of officers swooped into action and pulled Weary over on the shoulder of the West Loop, which just happens to be the busiest freeway in Houston. After stopping Weary, the officers ramped up their investigation and determined that the front license plate on Weary’s car was missing.
Weary was understandably irritated that the officiers had pulled him over in one of the most dangerous locations in Houston for doing something that occurs probably a million times in Houston each day. One thing led to another and, before you know it, the officers had Tasered Weary, arrested him and hauled him down to city jail. Verifying once again that it is virtually impossible to get someone processed out of jail in Houston in less than seven hours regardless of the offense, Weary was finally bailed out and able to head home at around 9:30 p.m. Quite a day off, eh?
As usual, HPD is contending that the officers acted reasonably in Tasering and arresting Weary. Count me as highly skeptical about that.
Update: The criminal case against Weary was dismissed in short order. Stay tuned.

It’s all Flutie’s fault?

Longhorn.jpgGeez, and I thought Texas Aggie fans were taking their team’s losses hard. But Aggie angst is nothing compared to what boiled over in Longhorn land after Texas’ upset loss to Kansas State last Saturday night that doomed the Horns’ BCS championship hopes:

An unhinged Texas Longhorn fan who blames Doug Flutieís televised analysis for the teamís upset Saturday threatened the former football star and his family in an electronic mail message, police said.
The threat, which was not detailed by police, was sent to the Doug Flutie Jr. Foundation for Autism early Sunday, police Lt. Paul Shastany said.
ìWe have intentions of finding this person and speaking to this person,î said Shastany. ìAs threats go, itís a pretty serious incident.î

Continue reading

It’s lonely being a Texans fan in Austin

downtown-austin.jpegThe Houston Texans recent improved play is not being noticed yet in Austin, at least according to this letter from a local Austin television programing director to Texans fan Brian over at Longhorn Law:

The last Texans game we aired (last Sunday) was tuned-in by just 21,000 households in Austin (a city with 589,000 households). By comparison, the Titans game we aired on Oct 8th (after Vince Young became quarterback) was watched by over 53,000 households (152% more football fanís homes). At one point during that game there were as many as 68,000 households tuned in. It was the most-watched ìearlyî game weíve aired all season. Actually, that game was watched by more Austin fans than any Texans game weíve aired going all the way back to October of last season – with two notable exceptions. The first is when the Texans played the Cowboys on October 15th (which you could expect to be highly watched) and the other, honestly, was when the Texans played the Titans on October 29th. [. . .]

Continue reading

The Blind Side of Big-Time College Football

Last week, the resignation of my friend, Iowa State head football coach Dan McCarney, prompted this post reflecting on how the pressures of big-time college football prompted a resignation that is quite likely contrary to the long term ability of Iowa State to remain competitive in big-time college football.

As if on cue, George Will, in this NY Times book review, provides his view on the new book by Michael Lewis of Moneyball fame, The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game.

In Moneyball, Lewis explored how the small-market Oakland Athletics were able to remain competitive against far richer clubs in Major League Baseball by emphasizing objective evaluation of players and, in so doing, introduced sabremetric statistical analysis to the general public.

As Will notes, Lewis “is advancing a new genre of journalism that shows how market forces and economic reasoning shape the evolution of sports.” Lewis’ latest book involves big-time college football, which — as noted earlier here — has long been a means by which universities in the U.S. have compromised academic integrity to rent athletically-gifted young men to serve as cash cows for the institutions.

As noted in this earlier post, the National Football League reaps the fruits (as if those teams really needed it) of an effectively free farm system that college football provides, while the vast majority of the universities — including Iowa State — either lose money or barely eke out a profit in their football programs.

Moreover, Lewis examines how the winds of change ripple down from the NFL to big-time college football and dictate the course of the college game. One case in point is Lawrence Taylor, who singlehandedly changed the nature of professional football by becoming the prototype of the huge, athletic and extraordinarily fast outside linebacker who could increase the pressure on the quarterback.

At about the same time as Taylor was wreaking havoc on QB’s, Bill Walsh‘s West Coast offense was spreading the field, which made it even more important for teams to find agile offensive linemen to block the likes of Taylor. Most important was to protect the QB’s blind side, so the position of left offensive tackle increased in importance and, as a result, the position’s economic value skyrocketed.

As demand increased in the NFL for the colleges to produce another kind of freak of nature to play what had been an obscure position but now was now one of the most important positions on the field, Lewis explains that the colleges were more than willing to compromise any notion of academic integrity to admit athletes who project to have the physical stature and talent to play the demanding left tackle position.

In short, it’s not just the star QB or running back who gets the royal treatment from the institutions in this day and age — potential left tackles are now included, too. Lewis’ book describes one of those freaks of nature, a freshman tackle at the University of Mississippi with an I.Q. of 80 who bounced from foster home to foster home as a youth.

Just as we should not be surprised that many folks enjoy betting illegally on college football, neither should we be shocked with the corruption in college football that Lewis examines in his book.

One of my uncles who played SEC football during the late 1920’s used to tell me how much money he was paid under the table even in those days. Moreover, there is no question that big-time college football — even as corrupt as it is — is a pretty darn entertaining form of corruption.

As noted in my earlier post, there is a model that would likely minimize the corrupt elements while not affecting the entertainment value of college football much. But it’s going to take leadership and courage from the top of the educational institutions to promote and implement such reform.

Unfortunately, those considerations were not on the minds of the Iowa State administrators last week as they began figuring out how to replace a very good football coach who had just left one of the most difficult jobs in his profession.

Similarly, my sense is University of Miami president Donna Shalala will not be contemplating those matters when she begins her search to replace Larry Coker later this month as head coach of one of the most storied programs in all of big-time college football.

That seems to be the tunnel vision that is generated from the sponsorship of minor league professional football by U.S. academic institutions.

2006 Weekly local football review

TexasvKSU.jpgTexans 13 Jaguars 10

If I didn’t know better, I’d think that the Texans (3-6) have the Jaguars’ (5-4) number.

In a game that stands for the proposition that you don’t have to play great offensively to win when the other team’s QB plays poorly, the Texans took advantage of four Jaguar QB David Garrard interceptions and a stout defensive effort to win their third game of the season, two of which have been over the Jags. The win was the Texans’ first road in almost two years and ended an NFL-leading 12 game losing streak in road games, The Texans mostly stunk offensively (306 yds total offense) , but they were at least well-balanced (148 yds rushing/158 yds passing) and most importantly, protected the football. Texans QB David Carr was knocked out with a sprained shoulder in the 4th quarter, but it did not look like a serious injury. The Texans now actually have a chance of stringing some wins together as their next four games are at home against the Bills (3-6), at the Jets (5-4) and Raiders (2-7), and at home against the Titans (2-7).

By the way, Chronicle sportswriter Richard Justice — who is presumably paid to notice such things — is just noticing that Texans kicker Kris Brown is not very good:

“K Kris Brown is becoming something of a concern. His miss of a 32-yard field goal late in the first half was his third miss in four games. He missed a more difficult kick, a 52-yarder, later in the game.”

Uh, Earth to Richard, Earth to Richard — Brown has been a concern for the past several seasons!

Continue reading

Re-evaluating the kickers

kickoff.jpgAs noted in earlier posts here and here, Aaron Schatz is the lead author of Pro Football Prospectus 2006, which is an innovative effort to develop the same type of objective statistical framework for evaluating professional football players that Bill James and other sabermetricians have developed and refined for evaluation of Major League Baseball players.
In this provocative NY Sunday Times op-ed, Schatz suggests that NFL teams are using the wrong criteria when they pay a large amount to acquire or retain a field goal kicker who has made almost of all of his field goal attempts in the previous season. Schatz’s argument is that a field goal kicker may have a “hot” season from time-to-time, but will almost always regress in the following season to his career success rate for field goals. On the other hand, Schatz notes that another key kicking statistic — average kickoff distance — shows far more consistency from season-to-season than field goal percentage. Kickoff distance is important because longer kickoffs generally give the team kicking off a better chance of pinning their opposition deep in their own territory, which reduces the risk of giving up touchdowns and field goals. A case in point is the Cardinals’ Neil Rackers:

No kicker reflects the difference between field goals and kickoffs better than Neil Rackers of the Arizona Cardinals. Last season, Rackers set an N.F.L. record with 40 field goals, and led the league by converting 95 percent of his attempts. But in 2004, he connected on 76 percent of his attempts. This year, Rackers is even worse, making just 67 percent of his tries. His high-profile misses include a 40-yard attempt that probably would have completed an upset and handed the Chicago Bears their first loss of the season.
Nonetheless, while his field-goal percentages have swung up and down over the past three seasons, Rackers has consistently ranked as one of the leagueís premier kickoff men. He led the N.F.L. in average kickoff distance in 2004 and 2005, and is fifth in the league this year.
This disparity in consistency between field goals and kickoffs means that N.F.L. teams are generally signing and drafting kickers based on the wrong skills.

A Good Football Coach Steps Away from a Coaching Graveyard

Dan McCarney.jpgDan McCarney, the “dean” of the Big 12 Conference football coaches, resigned under pressure on Wednesday as head football coach at Iowa State University after 12 seasons.

The announcement barely made a blip in the local Houston media, but Coach Mac’s resignation highlighted many aspects of the troubling direction of major college football.

I am biased about Coach McCarney, who is called Coach Mac by most everyone. As regular readers of this blog know, Coach Mac and I have been friends since growing up together in Iowa City, Iowa, where we played together on City High School’s championship football team in 1970.

I moved to Houston with my family shortly after finishing high school and Mac went on to play football at the University of Iowa in Iowa City, but we remained in contact over the years as I went to law school and began a legal career in Houston and Mac went on to the Iowa coaching staff after graduating from undergraduate school.

When Hayden Fry was hired to revive the downtrodden Iowa program in 1979, Coach Mac was one of the only coaches who Coach Fry retained from the previous coaching staff.

As with most of Coach Fry’s personnel decisions, retaining Coach Mac was a good one.

For the following decade, Coach Mac was a part of an extraordinary Iowa coaching staff that not only revived Iowa’s football fortunes, but also produced such outstanding head coaches as Wisconsin’s Barry Alvarez, Oklahoma’s Bob Stoops, Kansas State’s Bill Snyder, Iowa’s Kirk Ferentz and South Florida’s Jim Leavitt.

In 1990, Coach Mac followed Alvarez to Wisconsin, where they took over a 2-9 Badger program and, by 1993, had the team winning the Big Ten Conference championship with a 10-1-1 record, which included a Rose Bowl victory over UCLA.

The next year, Iowa State came calling for Coach Mac and the native Iowan was off to Ames for his first head coaching job.

Over the years, Mac and I have laughed many times about the fact that neither of us really had a clue of what he was getting into at Iowa State. We both knew that the university had long been a coaching graveyard and had eeked out a barely-winning record only a couple of times in the previous 15 years.

Ames is nice little college town, but it is in north central Iowa, pretty much in the middle of nowhere in the opinion of most good college football players. As a result, the football program has always struggled to attract good football prospects, who usually have sexier alternatives to living in central Iowa for four years.

The physical facilities of Iowa State’s football program were poor and the entire football budget at the time was just over $3 million, which was by far the smallest of any public school in the then newly-constituted Big 12 Conference that included such far better-funded programs as Texas, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, and Nebraska, just to name a few.

To make matters worse, Iowa State was a clear second fiddle in the state of Iowa to the University of Iowa, which has a far superior football tradition and an athletic budget more than twice as large as Iowa State’s.

Most folks assume that Kansas State was the toughest head coaching job in the United States before Bill Snyder resurrected it in the 1990’s, but I think a good case can be made that the Iowa State job was even more difficult before Coach Mac took over.

To Mac and Iowa State’s credit, they agreed at the outset that turning Iowa State’s program around was going to be a long-term project. As he did at Iowa and Wisconsin, Mac literally threw himself into the job of rebuilding the Cyclone football program, taking on any speaking engagement and going anywhere to promote Iowa State and its athletic teams.

An outstanding recruiter, Mac and his coaching staff began to expand Iowa State’s traditional Midwestern recruiting base to such football hotbeds as Texas, Florida and California. Mac began to challenge Iowa’s traditional toehold on the best recruits in the state of Iowa.

The progress was slow, though — Mac’s teams lost 42 or their 57 games during his first five seasons.

However, by the 2000 season, Mac and his staff had built a solid foundation for the program. Behind QB Sage Rosenfels (yes, the Texans’ backup QB), Iowa State went 9-3 during that season and won the university’s first post-season bowl game in the university’s 108-year football history (over Pitt in the Insight.com Bowl in Tucson).

That started a 40 game run where Mac’s teams were 25-15, a remarkable feat considering that Iowa State was competing in the brutally-tough Big 12 Conference and playing cross-state rival Iowa each season (Mac’s teams won six of their last nine games against their in-state rival).

By the 2004 and 2005 seasons, Coach Mac had his teams on the cusp of the Big 12 North Division title both seasons only to lose them in an agonizingly close final games in each season.

Nevertheless, after Iowa State had gone to only four bowl games in its history before Coach Mac’s tenure, Mac took the Cyclones to five bowl games in six years, winning two of them. Coming into the 2006 season, optimism was high that the Cyclones would again contend for the Big 12 North Division championship and go to yet another bowl game.

Alas, the 2006 season did not turn out as planned.

First, the Cyclones faced one of the toughest schedules in the country, including an initial stretch of Big 12 games at Texas, at home against Nebraska, at Oklahoma and at home against Texas Tech. Iowa State lost all four and were battered in the process, losing six senior starters to season-ending injury.

Lack of depth is a chronic problem at a place such as Iowa State, so a thin and deflated Cyclone team was smoked over the past two weeks by mediocre Kansas State and Kansas teams. That brought out the “what have you done for me lately” crowd in full force, many of whom were calling on Iowa State to fire Coach Mac despite the fact that few of them have any idea how difficult it is to win consistently at the top levels of major college football.

Suddenly, a little over a year after one of Mac’s best wins as a coach, Mac concluded it was not right for him to become a divisive issue for the university. Understanding Spike Dykes‘ advice that “you lose 10% of your support each season” as a college football coach, Mac understood that he was 20% in the hole at Iowa State based on that formula.

So, Coach Mac elected to resign as head football coach at Iowa State, a difficult job that he would have gladly continued to perform for the rest of his coaching days.

Take a moment to watch his performance during the press conference (click the video camera icon on the left side of the page) to announce his resignation — Mac exudes the class and passion with which he handled all of his duties at Iowa State. In this age of cold-hearted and businesslike coaches who are constantly posturing for the “better” job, it is refreshing to watch someone such as Mac, who wears his big heart and humanity on his sleeve.

Thus, 12 years after arriving at Iowa State, Mac leaves the football program in far better shape than he found it.

The football budget has quadrupled in size under Mac, but it remains the smallest of any public institution in the Big 12 Conference (Texas and A&M’s football budgets are at least 4 to 5 times larger than Iowa State’s). Mac worked behind the scenes continually to improve Iowa State’s facilities and they have improved substantially during his time there.

However, Cyclone athletic department officials are now attempting to raise another $135 million for facilities upgrades in an effort to keep up with the seemingly endless arms race of major college football. In one of the more bizarre aspects of Mac’s resignation, that imminent capital funds campaign was one of the key pressure points that prompted the resignation of the best fundraiser in the history of the Cyclone football program. So it goes in trying to keep up with the Joneses in the wacky world of college football.

After coaching the Iowa State team in its final two games this season, Mac will kick back for a few days, but then I suspect that he will back out looking for another opportunity. His motor is always running and he has a passionate love for coaching. Inasmuch as Mac is widely popular among his fellow coaches, I am confident that he will land on his feet.

However, I am not so sure about Iowa State. The institution is caught in the proverbial rat race of attempting to compete with far-better funded programs and the gap between Iowa State’s resources and those of programs such as Texas and A&M are likely to get even larger. The pressure of that competition has now prompted Iowa State’s administration to take what appears to be a huge risk that the program will decline from the solid foundation that Mac painstakingly built over the past 12 years.

Does Iowa State think that it is going to hire someone who will magically recruit better athletes to Ames than Mac? That’s highly doubtful as Mac is one of the best recruiters in the business and Ames is always going to be a difficult sell to all but a few of the best football prospects.

Does the institution think that it is going to hire someone who will coach better than Mac? Maybe, but Mac is a pretty darn good coach and how many more wins does Iowa State really believe it can achieve through slightly better coaching methods? And even Iowa State officials readily concede that it is highly unlikely that they will ever be able to find someone who can match Mac’s tireless enthusiasm for promoting the institution and the football program.

The bottom line is that seasons such as the one that the Cyclones and Mac are enduring this season are inevitable at a program such as Iowa State’s. That is one of the costs of attempting to compete with limited resources at the highest level of major college football.

That’s not a particularly pleasant reality, but it’s dubious decision-making to take big risks based on an emotional reaction to a disappointing result that is inevitable. That appears to be precisely what Iowa State is doing in letting Mac get away. Wouldn’t embracing a good coach who understands the institution’s limitations and has competed effectively in spite of them be far less risky and much more likely to result in continued success?

Ironically, the Cyclone family now finds itself looking for a new head coach who has the depth and characteristics of . . . well, Dan McCarney. Iowa State will be extremely fortunate if they find one.