Today is Opening Day for the Major League Baseball season and Houston, so it’s time for HCT’s annual preview of the Stros’ upcoming season (previous annual previews since 2004 are here). The Stros opening day roster is here over at Astros.com.
Despite an unlikely 42-24 run in the second half of last season that allowed the Stros to finish second with a 86-75 record behind the Cubs in the National League Central, there is really not much to be excited about in regard to the Stros this season. Last season’s club failed to make the playoffs for the third straight season since the Stros 2005 World Series appearance. This season’s club is substantially weaker than last season’s club and is even less likely to contend for a playoff spot.
As noted in previous previews, the Stros have been a team in decline for a long time even though generally superior pitching during the 2002-2006 seasons masked that downturn. Owner Drayton McLane cleaned house toward the end of the disastrous 2007 season and the club is now firmly in the process of rebuilding its farm system, which had deteriorated into one of MLB’s worst over the latter stages of the Biggio-Bagwell era. Even though Stros management continues to promote the delusion that the Stros can contend for a National League playoff spot, this season’s club has virtually no chance of doing so absent highly unlikely circumstances.
The Stros’ problems are really fairly simple to explain. Due to the decline in the farm system, and the failure of farm prospects Chris Burke, Morgan Ensberg and Jason Lane to pan out into at least average National League players, the Stros are deficient in a core of good young players who are capable of sustaining successful seasons. The Stros essentially have two very good players — 1B Lance Berkman and SP Roy Oswalt — one above-National League average hitter — LF Carlos Lee — a decent, but not great, closer — RP Jose Valverde — and a player in his prime who has the potential to develop into an above-National League player — RF Hunter Pence. The rest of the club is an amalgamation of below-National League position players and a pitching staff taht will struggle to be National League-average overall this season. That’s not much of a prescription for a successful season.
Last season’s club was a poor hitting club that generated 46 fewer runs than an average National League club would have using the same number of outs ("RCAA"), which was 12th among the 16 National League teams. This season’s club is unlikely to hit as well as last season’s club and the way in which Stros management dealt with the situation reveals why.
In a cost-cutting move during these lean economic times (partly a consequence of over-paying for players during good times), Stros management allowed 3B Ty Wigginton to leave as a free agent after the best season of his career. Inasmuch as the club lacks any ready prospect at the position, the Stros will run a platoon of Geoff Blum and newly-acquired Reds castoff Jeff Keppinger out there every day.
A Blum platoon with over-the-hill Aaron Boone was the original plan, but Boone will miss the season after being diagnosed with a heart ailment and undergoing surgery. Beginning with the 2003 season in which former Stros manager Jimy Williams probably cost the Stros the National League Central title by insisting on platooning Blum with the clearly superior Ensberg, Blum has deteriorated to a point where he is not even close to being an adequate reserve, much less a starter. He has had under a .300 on-base average in five of the past six seasons, has batted .247 BA/.300 OBA/.371 SLG in about 2,000 plate appearances during that stretch, and has generated 100 fewer runs than a National League-average hitter during that period. Thus, the suggestion that Blum is likely to be even close to a National League-average 3B borders on the absurd.
In fact, the Stros would probably be better off moving over-the-hill SS Miguel Tejeda over to 3B and starting slick-fielding minor league SS Tommy Manzella at shortstop, which at least would provide a defensive upgrade. Good defense is going to be particularly important this season given that the Stros’ old and low-strikeout starting rotation. On the other hand, it will take a minor miracle for starters Mike Hampton and Russ Ortiz — who have pitched a total of about 150 innings between them over the past three seasons — to pitch a total of 150 innings between them this season. One shudders to think who will make up the difference.
Thus, this is likely to be a brutal season for the Stros. The most likely result is a return to the 73 win-level of the 2007 season and there is a real chance that the improving Pirates may finally move ahead of the Stros and relegate the local club to the National League Central basement. The Cubs again are the class of the NL Central and my sense is that the Reds are the most likely club to make a jump up the standings this season. The good news for the Stros is that neither the Brewers nor the Cardinals have improved, either, so at least there is likely to be a muddle of mediocrity underneath the Cubs in the division. However, there is virtually no chance that the NL Wild-Card playoff team will come out of the NL Central.
As with prior seasons, I will continue my periodic reviews of the Stros during the season ("Stros 2009 Season Review, Part __"). This season I will post them after each quarter of the season, which works out to be after each 40 game segment of the season. So, look for my first season review this season after around mid-May, give or take a few days in the event of postponed games. The best sources for keeping up with the Stros on a day-to-day basis are Lisa Gray’s insightful Stros blog, the reliable Crawfish Boxes blog, and the Chronicle’s Zac Levine’s blog. Zac will also provide reports via Twitter this season.