Following up on my concierge health care experience

DrWilliamLentMDThis post from about a year ago explored the reasons why my friend and personal physician — internist Bill Lent, MD — decided to convert his internal medicine practice to a concierge practice in which he limited his practice to 600 patients who pay $1,500 per year to retain his services. Inasmuch as I am blessed with good health, the only time I see Bill in most years is for my annual physical, which was this past week. As always, it was good to catch up with him and hear his thoughts about the first year of a concierge practice.

In short, Bill’s experience has been overwhelmingly positive. The funds generated through his patients’ retainer payments have relieved Bill of the financial pressure that had been mounting over the past decade to increase patient visits as Medicare and private medical insurers systematically reduced the amount paid to doctors for such visits. Released from that pressure, Bill is now able to spend more time with each patient, which Bill believes provides the patient with better quality service. The response from Bill’s patients has been uniformly positive.

Although Bill’s workload has been reduced from the standpoint that he no longer feels compelled to see more and more patients to maintain revenue levels in the face of reduced insurance payments, Bill has had to spend quite a bit of time over the past year in the process of computerizing his patients records. Part of the deal for patients in signing up for the concierge service is that their records are digitized so that the patient, Bill or any other doctor who the patient retains can review the records from anywhere via the Web. That perk has required a considerable expenditure of effort over the past year in digitizing those records, but now that the process is largely complete, Bill will spend far less time in future years as he simply amends a patient’s computerized record with each visit.

There have been a number of pleasant surprises in Bill’s first year of the concierge practice. For example, Bill was initially concerned that a number of his less affluent patients would opt not to participate because of the retainer payment. Surprisingly, however, his patient base has remained quite diverse from a socioeconomic standpoint — even a large number of his elderly patients on Medicare elected to participate despite the fact that Medicare doesn’t cover any of the retainer payment.

One of those is a long-time patient who is a retired bus driver with a host of medical problems that Bill has helped control for years. Rather than taking the risk of moving on to another physician, the retired bus driver’s five children decided to split payment of the retainer between themselves so that their father could remain one of Bill’s patients.

But the most pleasant aspect of the concierge practice is that Bill is back to doing what he loves to do — taking the requisite amount of time to visit with patients about their symptoms and then diagnosing the nature of the problem. He no longer feels rushed to complete a patient visit so that he can move on to the next patient in an effort to fill his quota for the day.

Bill did have one foreboding experience in the transition to a concierge practice. Being the kind of fellow that he is, Bill offered at no cost to his former patients who opted out of the concierge practice to help them find another internist to replace him as their personal physician. Many of Bill’s former patients took him up on his offer and he accommodated each of them. However, in so doing, Bill discovered that a growing number of internists and family practitioners in the Houston area are no longer accepting patients on Medicare because of the economic constraints of taking on such patients. As the number of primary care physicians continues to decline across the country, where are patients on Medicare going to find a primary care physician if this trend continues?

So, one of Houston’s best internists was successful in saving his practice from the perverse impact of America’s Byzantine health care finance system. As I noted in the previous post, if such entrepreneurial spirit can succeed in reviving a doctor’s practice in the current highly-regulated health care finance system, then imagine what might happen if we unleashed the power of the marketplace to reform the health care finance system and the delivery of health care, as well?

3 thoughts on “Following up on my concierge health care experience

  1. Congratulations to Dr. Bill Lent and his patients. He has just become Dr. Marcus Welby and his patients are now his valued medical family members. Concierge medicine is nothing short of the return to the days of Dr. Welby, when patients paid the doctor directly for his services; when the doctor worked directly for his patients. There was no meddlesome middleman.
    I opened one of the first concierge practice in the country 8 years ago. I could never return to practicing fast-food medicine. Like Dr. Lent, I am one of the happy internists, who enjoys going to work in the morning.
    Steven D. Knope, M.D.
    Author, Concierge Medicine, A New System to
    Get the Best Healthcare (Greenwood/Praeger, 2008)
    http://www.conciergemedicinemd.com
    http://www.greenwood.com/catalog/C35477.aspx

  2. I think such arrangements are ever increasingly smart decisions for doctors. I heard about a dentist who was having some problems getting payments from his patients so he fired every client who had ever been late with a payment, raised his prices, and told the remaining clients that to remain clients they had to refer one patient to him per year. He’s just as busy as he was before but all his clients pay on time and he’s much happier. Makes sense to me.

  3. I am a corporate lawyer and usually do not have time to spend time waiting in doctors’ offices. I generally look for expedited care, VIP treament and 24-hour access to my personal physician via cell phone and email. I was looking for a concierge medical facility or plan since a year almost and lately found Elitehealth.com providing more than my wishlist. I have registered along with my wife and have made a couple of visits to our primary care physician already. We are quite pleased with the experience and would post further feedback in a few weeks time again.
    http://www.elitehealth.com/concierge_healthcare.php

Leave a Reply