Be careful, Mr. Wagoner

General Motors General Motors CEO Rick Wagoner made some interesting public comments this past week in Dallas regarding the besieged automaker’s bankruptcy prospects:

"Under any scenario we can imagine, our financial position, or cash position, will remain robust through the rest of this year," Mr. Wagoner said Thursday while in Dallas to speak to a business organization. He said the company has plenty of options to shore up its finances beyond 2008, although he declined to outline them.

The comments failed to boost investor sentiment as GM shares fell 6.2% to $9.69 in 4 p.m. New York Stock Exchange composite trading Thursday. The stock has been trading at its lowest levels in more than 50 years as concerns mount about the company’s financial position amid a steep decline in U.S. sales.

GM and other U.S. auto makers are reeling as the slow U.S. economy depresses sales and as high gasoline prices push many would-be buyers to small, more-fuel-efficient vehicles and away from the higher-margin SUVs and trucks. Through June, for instance, GM’s U.S. sales slipped 16%, more than offsetting strength in overseas markets.

GM has about $24 billion in cash but is burning an estimated $3 billion a quarter, prompting talk that it will need a significant cash influx to get to 2010.

"We have no thought of [bankruptcy] whatsoever," Mr. Wagoner said in response to an audience question during the Dallas event.

Now, I am not involved with GM, but I have been involved over the past 30 years in my share of big company reorganizations. Contrary to Wagoner’s statements, GM has almost certainly "thought" of bankruptcy and GM management probably continues to examine whether a reorganization under chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code makes sense for the company, which it just might. Frankly, not to examine such alternatives would be egregious mismanagement. Any seasoned investor knows this and the market is clearly pricing that risk by lowering the company’s stock price.

So, despite all that, if GM ends up in bankruptcy, is Wagoner at risk of being indicted for misleading investors regarding the company’s ongoing bankruptcy analysis? Stated another way, will Wagoner be indicted for breaching the obligation to throw in the towel?

Leave a Reply