Comparing bad off-season deals

wagner2.jpgausmus.jpgInasmuch as Roger Clemens still has not let the Stros know whether he is going to play next season, the Stros have been twiddling their thumbs so far this off-season considering silly notions such as re-signing Brad Ausmus rather than going out and competing for a couple of free agent hitters that the club really needs.
However, it helps me to remain optimistic about the Stros’ management when I read that former Stros closer Billy Wagner has just taken the Mets to the cleaners for $43 million over the next three years with an option for a fourth season that could push the total compensation over $50 million. Now, don’t get me wrong. Wagner is a very good closer and a lefty to boot. However, $50 million over four years for a 34 year old pitcher who had season-ending arm problems as recently as the season before last? Although Wagner’s runs saved against average (“RSAA,” explained here) was a very good 26 last season, he has had RCAA’s of 10, 13 and 15 in three of the past five seasons. That’s decent production, but not $12.50 – $14.3 million per year-type of production. The Stros will likely sign the more effective Brad Lidge for an annual salary probably around a third of what the Mets are paying Wagner.
With Jeff Bagwell’s deal, the Stros are closing the book on their final long-term, overpriced contract. Inasmuch as those contracts limit the flexibility of a mid-market club such as the Stros to make the type of “tweaking” acquisitions necessary to remain competitive, I am glad that Stros management is not overbidding for high-priced stars (remember Carlos Beltran?). Nevertheless, the Stros need to be careful at overpaying — albeit at a far lesser rate — unproductive players such as Ausmus. Throw a couple of million at Ausmus, plus another million or so at an equally unproductive player such as Vizcaino, and — after awhile — you’re talking about some real money.

One thought on “Comparing bad off-season deals

  1. Giving the pitching staff’s apparent level of trust in Ausmus and the relative lack of clearly more attractive options, I don’t think keeping him around for another year, two at the outside, to give, say, Quintero more time to develop, is particularly crazy. Vizcaino, on the other hand…

Leave a Reply