After killing his neighbor three years ago and dumping the butchered body into Galveston Bay and then winning an acquittal in his subsequent 2003 murder trial, Robert Durst — an heir to a New York family’s real estate fortune — pleaded guilty Wednesday to two counts of bail jumping and one of evidence tampering that will allow Durst to get out of prison in less than a year. Here are earlier posts on the Durst case.
The deal came just two hours after state appellate judge Judge Jackson B. Smith Jr. had removed removed Galveston State District Judge Susan Criss from the case. Judge Criss had refused the plea deal earlier in the week, which was yet another strange twist in a case. Judge Criss had been rebuked by the appellate court earlier this year for setting Durst’s bail at $3 billion dollars on the three relatively minor charges after Durst had been acquitted in the murder trial (the appellate court reduced the bail to $450,000). With credit for time served both before and after his murder trial, Durst will likely be freed from prison early next year under state prison system rules.
The recusal came after sheriff’s investigators testified before Judge Smith that Judge Criss had given them information in December that prompted an investigation into possible jury tampering during Durst’s murder trial. Although the investigators found no evidence of criminal activity by jurors or anyone involved in the trial, they did secretly tape-record conversations between Durst and a juror who visited him in jail after the trial. Nevertheless, Durst did admit in the taped conversation that he skipped a court appearance after he posted a $300,000 bond in the murder case in September 2001.
As a result, Durst’s defense attorneys Dick DeGuerin and Mike Ramsey maintained that Judge Criss’ involvement in the jury tampering investigation that led to Durst’s taped admission made her a potential witness in Durst’s bail-jumping case, and that such involvement required her to be removed from adjudicating the case. When Judge Criss refused to recuse herself from the case earlier this week, Judge Smith did so in about 10 minutes on Wednesday.