DeVany’s Top Ten Reasons Not to Run Marathons

marathon runner The Chicago Marathon was over this past weekend, which resulted in the typical dozens of hospitalizations of participants.

That reminds me to pass along health and nutrition expert Art DeVany’s top 10 reasons not to run marathons (here is a previous post on the risks of long-distance running). Art’s summary of each reason is below, but you will have to subscribe to Art’s insightful site on fitness, health, aging nuturion and exercise to read Art’s elaboration on each reason:

10. Marathon running damages the liver and gall bladder and alters biochemical markers adversely. HDL is lowered, LDL is increased, Red blood cell counts and white blood cell counts fall. The liver is damaged and gall bladder function is decreased. Testosterone decreases.

9. Marathon running causes acute and severe muscle damage. Repetitive injury causes infiltration of collagen (connective tissue) into muscle fibers.

8. Marathon running induces kidney disfunction (renal abnormalities).

7. Marathon running causes acute microthrombosis in the vascular system.

6. Marathon running elevates markers of cancer. S100beta is one of these markers. Tumor necrosis factor, TNF-alpha, is another.

5. Marathon running damages your brain. The damage resembles acute brain trauma. Marathon runners have elevated S100beta, a marker of brain damage and blood brain barrier dysfunction. There is S100beta again, a marker of cancer and of brain damage.

4. Marathons damage your heart. From Whyte, et al Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2001 May, 33 (5) 850-1, “Echocardiographic studies report cardiac dysfunction following ultra-endurance exercise in trained individuals. Ironman and half-Ironman competition resulted in reversible abnormalities in resting left ventricular diastolic and systolic function. Results suggest that myocardial damage may be, in part, responsible for cardiac dysfunction, although the mechanisms responsible for this cardiac damage remain to be fully elucidated.”

3. Endurance athletes have more spine degeneration.

The number two reason not to run marathons:

2. At least four particiants of the Boston Marathon have died of brain cancer in the past 10 years. Purely anecdotal, but consistent with the elevated S100beta counts and TKN-alpha measures. Perhaps also connected to the microthrombi of the endothelium found in marathoners.

And now ladies and gentlemen the number one reason not to run marathons:

1. The first marathon runner, Phidippides, collapsed and died at the finish of his race. [Jaworski, Curr Sports Med Rep. 1005 June; 4 (3), 137-43.]

Now there is a recommendation for a healthy activity. The original participant died in the event. But, this is not quite so unusual; many of the running and nutritional gurus of the past decade or two died rather young. Pritikin, Sheehy, Fixx, and Atkins, among many other originators of “healthy” practices died at comparatively young ages. Jack LaLanne, the only well-known guru to advocate body building, will outlive us all.

2 thoughts on “DeVany’s Top Ten Reasons Not to Run Marathons

  1. So we’re takling about elite runners or everybody who runs marathons? At what mileage does the research show problems– 22, 15, or whatever? What is the percentage of the four brain cancer victims to the entire 10-year finisher’s list? Do we know what kind of shape Phidippides was in?

  2. Thanks for sharing this. I really thought at first that running is a good exercise and has a good effects to our body. But, it has a bad effect, it decreases our testosterone levels. I do a lot exercises everyday and I think I’m going to skip running for now.

Leave a Reply